Who to hire, and what to ask
Deciding what to do

Who to hire for furniture work, and what to ask them

A conservator, a restorer, a refinisher, an upholsterer and an appraiser do five different jobs. Your condition report, not the piece's age, is what tells you which one you need.

Start here Essentials

At minimum this chapter asks you to work out which trade your report points to, send that person the report and the photographs, and get the examination in writing before anything is agreed. The directory's structure and the fuller question list are Go deeper on a first pass.

  1. Read your own report and say which of five jobs this is. The report decides, not the piece's age (section 1, section 2).
  2. Decide whether an appraisal comes first. Where value is in question it comes before the work (section 3).
  3. Send the report and the photographs, and ask for the examination in writing. Before agreeing to anything (section 5).
  4. Ask the questions before you agree. Fees, insurance, terms and what will be removed (section 6).

Minimum time: about 40 minutes to prepare and send one inquiry. Done when: you have a written examination or estimate in hand, and your report says what was agreed.

1. Five different trades, and a few more Understand

"Furniture guy" covers several occupations with different training, different goals and different prices, and picking the wrong one is how people get work they did not want. Here they are, with what each is.

Who does what
TradeWhat they doTypically will not take onWhat hiring them costs you in original material
Conservator (wooden artifacts)Examination, documentation, treatment and preventive care on objects valued for their history, working to a professional code of ethicsRoutine cosmetic work on ordinary furniture, and anything where the owner wants the object to look newLeast, by design. Their training is oriented to keeping original material and documenting what is done
Conservator (textiles)The same approach applied to upholstered furniture, show covers and the textile componentsStructural woodworkLeast, within their specialty
Conservation technicianSpecific treatment activities, working with or under the supervision of a conservatorIndependent judgment about what treatment an object should haveDepends on the supervising conservator's plan
RestorerRepair and reinstatement, often including replacing missing elements so a piece reads as wholeVaries widely; the title is not regulatedVaries. Restoration by definition can involve adding non-original material
RefinisherRemoving an existing surface coating and applying a new oneStructural conservation, appraisalMost: the existing surface and any wear patterns in it
General furniture repair shopJoints, breaks, drawers, hardware, everyday structural workMuseum-standard documentation; sometimes fine finishingVaries with the shop and the brief you give it
UpholstererRebuilding seats and backs: webbing, springs, padding, coversWood finishing, structural frame conservationOld covers, old padding, and the evidence in them, unless you ask for them to be kept
AppraiserEstablishing value, for insurance, sale, division or decisionAny physical work on the pieceNothing: an appraisal is non-destructive
Licensed pest control operatorFumigation and insect treatmentAny furniture repairNothing structural, though treatments can affect finishes
Lead-safe certified contractorWork disturbing paint in pre-1978 housing, under the federal ruleFurniture repair as suchDepends on the work

Two things in that table deserve emphasis because they are commonly misunderstood.

Definition Conservator and restorer are not opposites. The American Institute for Conservation defines restoration as treatment procedures intended to return an object to a known or assumed state, often through adding non-original material, and defines treatment as something that may consist of stabilization, restoration, or both. So restoration sits inside conservation as one kind of treatment. The organization also notes that conservator is the preferred term in the United States, and that professionals elsewhere often identify as art restorers, which it attributes partly to differences in language rather than to a difference in practice.

Most of these titles are not regulated. Anybody can describe themselves as a restorer. What the conservation profession offers instead of a license is a membership that was reviewed, which section 4 covers, and what an owner can do in every case is ask for the plan in writing before agreeing, which section 5 covers. A commercial refinishing source this manual cites elsewhere makes the same point from the trade side, noting that there are no certificates of authenticity for restorers or dealers, and advising anyone in doubt to use a certified appraiser.

2. Reading your own report for the answer

The useful question is not "how old is my piece" but "what does my report say is wrong with it." Here is how the findings map onto trades.

From a finding on the report to a trade
What your report saysWhere it usually pointsWhat to send
Loose joints, no breaks, a piece you use dailyA general furniture repair shop, or yourself: see The furniture repairs worth doing yourselfThe condition sheet and photographs of the joints
A break across the grain in a load-bearing memberA general repair shop for an ordinary piece; a conservator where history or value is in questionPhotographs showing the member, the direction of the break and its length
Lifting or lost veneer, inlay or marquetryA conservator in wooden artifacts. The specialty explicitly covers veneer, marquetry and boulleClose photographs, the area, and what pressing told you
A finish that softened under mineral spiritsA furniture conservator. The cleaning guidance names this result as a stop and a referralWhat you tested with, where, and what happened
A painted surface needing more than dustingA furniture conservator, per the same guidancePhotographs, and the paint question from the hazards chapter
A failed finish on an ordinary piece you have decided to refinishA refinisherYour decision from What not to do to old furniture, and what you want kept
Sagging seats, torn covers, a frame that needs rebuildingAn upholsterer; a textiles conservator where the covers themselves matterPhotographs of the frame where it shows, and what is under the seat if visible
Active infestationA licensed pest control operator, or a conservator who can route itThe hazards sheet, hole sizes, powder color, and your sweep and recheck dates
"It might be worth something"An appraiser, before any of the aboveEverything you have, including the identification sheet

The Park Service's cleaning leaflet is the source of three of those referrals and it is worth noting how specific they are. It names a furniture conservator for painted surfaces beyond dusting unless staff are trained, for a finish that softens under the mineral spirits test, and for questions about patina and whether a surface should be cleaned. Those are not vague cautions; they are three defined results that end the owner's part of the job.

Limits

This manual does not recommend anyone, does not say what work costs, and does not say that a conservator is the right answer for every piece. It has no basis for any of the three.

It is also worth being even-handed about interest. A conservator's training and professional code orient them toward keeping original material, which is a position with its own commitments, and the refinishing trade's complaint that conservation advice gets overgeneralized from museum-quality pieces is a fair one, set out in What not to do to old furniture, and why. The hiring guidance itself says conservators do not always agree about treatments. So match the trade to what your report says and to the decision you made, rather than to the piece's age, and ask more than one where the answer matters.

3. When value decides the order

One finding changes the order of everything else: if the piece might be worth something, the appraiser comes first.

This is the point on which the two sides of the refinishing argument agree, which is set out at length in What not to do to old furniture, and why. The short version: the conservation position rests on the irreversibility of removing original material, and the commercial refinishing source that argues hardest against that position closes by advising anyone with doubts to contact a certified appraiser. Neither can recover what has already been done.

What an appraiser does that nobody else in the table does: establishes a value, for a stated purpose, as of a date. The purpose matters, because the value for insurance, for a sale and for dividing an estate can differ, and a useful appraisal says which it is.

What an appraiser does not do: physical work on the piece. That separation is a feature rather than a limitation, and it is worth preserving. Somebody who both values a piece and offers to buy it, or to work on it, has an interest in the number.

Ask the authority This manual does not say when an appraisal is worth the cost, because it does not know the cost or the value. The signals that raise the question are in that chapter's section on who settles it: an unusual or early-looking piece, documentation or provenance, something you were told was valuable by someone who might know, construction that looks hand-made throughout, or simply that you would be upset to learn afterwards that it had mattered.

4. Finding somebody

For conservators, the American Institute for Conservation runs a directory, "Find a Professional Member." Here is how it works and what it does and does not promise, from the page itself.

How to search. You choose a specialty, material or service from drop-down lists, then optionally set a search area with an address and a radius in miles, leaving it blank to see listings regardless of location. Relevant paths for furniture include Objects then Furniture, and Wooden Artifacts then its sub-entries; services include Treatment, Examination and Preventive Conservation.

The search logic catches people out. The page states that the logic is cumulative: checking two options returns only those who specialize in both, not those who specialize in either. It suggests selecting choices within one specialty per search. So a search that returns nothing is often an over-narrow search rather than an empty region.

What listing means. The page says listed professionals have been reviewed, after careful review of their training, knowledge and experience by a body of their peers, and have shown strict adherence to the organization's Code of Ethics and Guidelines for Practice. That is a meaningful signal and it is a peer review of credentials rather than a license or a guarantee of any particular job.

What listing does not mean. It is an opt-in system: professional members choose whether to appear, so absence from the directory is not evidence about anybody. The page also says the tool drops a member whose membership has expired, which means the listing is current but also that good people fall off it.

One thing this manual will not tell you. The page does not state that searching is free, so this manual does not claim it is. Open it and see.

For the other trades there is no equivalent directory this manual can point to. What is available is the ordinary diligence of asking for references, asking to see work in progress, and asking the questions in section 6. For upholsterers and repair shops, a conservator or a museum's collections staff will often know who locally does careful work, and that is a question worth asking even of someone you are not hiring.

5. Ask for it on paper

This is the part of the chapter that protects you, and it comes from the hiring guidance rather than from this manual's caution.

The American Institute for Conservation's guidance says a conservator should provide a written preliminary examination report containing a description of the proposed treatment, the expected results and the estimated cost, for your review and approval before treatment begins. And that after the work, a treatment report should list the materials and procedures used, may where appropriate include photographic records of the condition before and after, and may include recommendations for continued care and maintenance. It adds that written and photographic records should be unambiguous and that all records should be kept for reference.

Three reasons to insist on this even with somebody you trust, and the third is the one people miss:

  • It makes the proposal specific. "Clean it up and sort the joints" and "remove the existing coating, reglue four joints with PVA, and apply two coats of satin polyurethane" are different jobs, and only one of them can be agreed to.
  • It gives you the chance to say no to part of it, before rather than after.
  • It becomes part of the piece's record. What went into those joints, and when, is exactly what your condition report's What was done sheet exists to hold, and what the next repairer will need in twenty years.

The guidance also suggests, for a large collection or a large job, having one object treated first before entering into a major contract. The domestic version is obvious: if you have six chairs, have one done.

6. The questions

The hiring guidance sets out what to establish about charges and terms. It presents these as instructions rather than as a numbered list, and there are eight topics in it. Here they are in its order, with the manual's note on why each matters.

What to establish before agreeing, after the AIC hiring guidance
TopicWhat the guidance saysWhy it matters
The basis of chargesThe conservator should be willing to discuss the basis for all chargesHourly, fixed or per-object changes what an overrun means
Rates for preliminary examinationDetermine whether there are separate rates for preliminary examination and evaluationThe examination may be a job of its own
Whether that is deductibleDetermine whether preliminary charges are separate from, or deductible against, a later contractDecides what a second opinion actually costs you
InsuranceAsk about insuranceThe piece will be in somebody else's building
Payment termsAsk about payment termsDeposits and stage payments change your position if the work stalls
ShippingAsk about shippingTransport is where furniture gets damaged; see the moving instructions in Keeping furniture from getting worse
Additional chargesAsk about additional chargesMaterials, storage and unexpected findings
Waiting periodInquire whether a waiting period is needed before new work can be acceptedGood people are often booked; knowing this early changes your plan rather than your choice

To those eight, this manual adds three of its own, drawn from the decisions the rest of the manual has had you make:

  • What exactly will be removed, and what will be added? This is the question that distinguishes the trades in practice, and it is better than asking what someone calls themselves.
  • What will this make harder or impossible later? A reversible treatment and an irreversible one can look identical when finished.
  • Will you keep and return anything you take off? Original hardware, a show cover, a detached molding. The answer is usually yes if asked beforehand and no if asked afterwards.

7. The warning signs

The hiring guidance names three things to be wary of, and they are specific enough to be useful rather than being general advice about trusting your instincts. Be wary of someone who:

  • proposes to perform a quick and inexpensive restoration job;
  • is reluctant to discuss in detail the materials and methods to be used;
  • will not permit you to see work in progress.

Each of those is diagnostic rather than merely off-putting. A quick and inexpensive proposal on a job that is neither usually means the proposer has not examined the piece, or is planning the fastest route rather than the appropriate one. Reluctance to discuss materials is the single most informative response you can get, because materials are where the irreversible decisions live. And work in progress is where you would see whether the brief is being followed.

The same guidance makes a point that reads oddly at first and is worth taking seriously: conservators do not always agree about treatments. It suggests judging quality on technical and structural aspects as well as appearance, and speaking to several conservators. So a second opinion that differs is not evidence that one of them is incompetent; it is the normal state of a field making judgments about particular objects. That is also why the written examination matters: two different written proposals can be compared, where two conversations cannot.

8. See it: Marcus makes two calls See it

Fictional example

Marcus's four oak chairs. Two rack at the rear joints, one has a cross-grain line in a rear seat rail, all four have a gummy surface. He wants to eat dinner on them. He paid $60 for the set.

What his report points to, chair by chair: chairs one and two are loose joints with no break, which is a general repair shop or the repairs chapter. Chair three needs nothing structural. Chair four has what looks like a cross-grain crack in a load-bearing member, which is not a home repair.

The value question: Marcus answered "probably nothing special" rather than "no idea," on the basis that these are ordinary factory dining chairs with machine-cut joinery and no marks. So no appraisal step, and he writes that reasoning down rather than just the answer.

Call one, to a general furniture repair shop. He sends the condition sheet, four photographs of the racking joints with a ruler in frame, and one sentence: "Two of four chairs rack at the rear seat rail joints, about half an inch at the top of the back, springing back, no visible cracks. What would you need to look at before quoting?" He does not say "they need regluing."

Call two, about chair four. Same shop, separate question, with photographs of the rail from three angles and a ruler along the line. "There is a line across the grain in the rear seat rail, about 3 inches, two thirds along. A fingernail catches on it. The chair is out of use. Is this something you repair, and what would you want to see?"

What he asks before agreeing to anything: the basis of the charges, whether looking at it is charged separately, what exactly would be removed or added, and whether anything taken off would be kept.

Known: the condition findings, and that two chairs have no break.

Assumed: that the line in chair four's rail is a crack through the member. Under that assumption the chair stays out of use and goes out for an opinion.

Still open: whether repairing chair four is worth doing. That is a judgment about the cost of the work against what the chair is to Marcus, and this manual has no view, because it does not know what either costs. What it can say is that the question is settled by a written estimate rather than by guessing, and that the answer may be no.

Why he sends observations rather than a diagnosis: a shop reading "two chairs need regluing" answers the question Marcus asked. A shop reading the measurements and seeing the photographs answers the question the chairs pose, which may be a different one.

The guidance behind this chapter:

  • What is conservation? (American Institute for Conservation): the definitions in section 1, including restoration as a kind of treatment, and the specialties covering furniture, upholstery, frames, veneer and marquetry.
  • Find a professional member (American Institute for Conservation): how the directory searches, the cumulative logic, the peer review, and that it is opt-in.
  • Hiring a conservation professional (American Institute for Conservation): the written examination report, the eight topics in section 6, the three warning signs, and the statement that conservators do not always agree about treatments.
  • Cleaning wood furniture (National Park Service, Conserve O Gram 7/1): the three specific results that it says end the owner's part and call for a furniture conservator.

9. Practice: the first message Practice

Minimum: one inquiry written and sent, with observations rather than a diagnosis, and the questions you will ask listed. Time: about 40 minutes. Materials: your condition report, your photographs, and the export from your furniture file.

  1. Decide which trade, from the table in section 2, and write down why that one.
  2. Check whether the value question changes the order. If it might be worth something, the first call is an appraiser.
  3. Assemble what you will send: the identification and condition sheets, three to six photographs with a scale in frame, and your plan sheet showing what you want.
  4. Write the message in observations. Describe what you measured and saw. Put any diagnosis of your own at the end, or leave it out.
  5. Ask for a written preliminary examination with proposed treatment, expected results and estimated cost, before agreeing to anything.
  6. List the questions you will ask from section 6, including the three about what will be removed, what it forecloses, and what will be returned.
  7. Record it on the report: who you contacted, what you sent, what the written reply said, and what was agreed.
Go deeper

The two-proposal exercise. Send the same observations and photographs to two people, and compare the written replies rather than the prices. What you are looking for is whether they describe the same problem, propose the same materials, and foresee the same risks. The hiring guidance says conservators do not always agree about treatments, so a difference is not a scandal; what it gives you is a far better understanding of the decision than either proposal alone, and it is usually the point at which you understand what you are actually choosing between.

10. Your piece Your piece

11. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Did you choose the trade from what your report says rather than from the piece's age?
  • If value might be in question, is the appraisal step first, or is there a written reason why not?
  • Does your inquiry describe observations with measurements, rather than opening with a diagnosis?
  • Did you ask for the examination and estimate in writing before agreeing?
  • Did you ask what will be removed, what will be added, and what will be returned?
  • Is the exchange recorded on the report: who, what you sent, what they said, what was agreed?

Worked example

Marcus's two inquiries split one piece of furniture into two separate questions with different answers, describe measurements rather than conclusions, keep his own diagnosis out of the opening, and attach his reasoning on the value question rather than just its answer. Checked against the criteria they pass on all six. The detail that makes them work is the splitting: a single message about "four chairs that need work" would have got one answer to four different problems.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing the trade from the piece's age. "It is old, so a conservator" and "it is ordinary, so a refinisher" are both guesses; the report says which.
  • Opening with your diagnosis. You will get an answer to your question rather than to the piece's.
  • Bundling several problems into one inquiry. Different faults go to different answers, and sometimes to different trades.
  • Agreeing on a conversation. Two written proposals can be compared; two conversations cannot.
  • Treating a differing second opinion as proof that one is wrong. The hiring guidance says conservators do not always agree about treatments.
  • Reading absence from the directory as a verdict. It is opt-in, and it drops expired memberships.
  • Forgetting to ask for removed parts back. The answer is usually yes beforehand and no afterwards.
  • Letting the work start before the value question is settled. That order does not reverse.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not tell you what work costs, does not recommend anyone, and does not tell you whether a given repair is worth doing, which is a judgment about a cost this manual does not know against a value it does not know. What it gives you is the match between a finding and a trade, the paperwork that makes a proposal comparable, and the questions that surface the irreversible parts before they happen. The decision about whether to change the piece is What not to do to old furniture, and why.

12. Knowledge check and scenario

Is a restorer the opposite of a conservator?
No. The American Institute for Conservation defines restoration as treatment procedures intended to return an object to a known or assumed state, often by adding non-original material, and defines treatment as something that may consist of stabilization, restoration or both. Restoration therefore sits inside conservation as one kind of treatment. The practical difference between practitioners is how much non-original material they consider appropriate on a given object, which is why the useful question is what will be removed and added rather than what someone calls themselves.
Your search of the conservators' directory returns nobody within fifty miles. What is the most likely explanation?
An over-narrow search. The directory's logic is cumulative, so selecting two options returns only members who specialize in both rather than either, and the page suggests choosing within one specialty per search. Widen the specialty, then widen or clear the radius. Remember too that it is opt-in, so absence is not evidence about who practices in your area.
Why ask for the examination in writing even from somebody you trust?
Three reasons. It makes the proposal specific enough to agree or refuse in parts. It lets you compare two proposals, which two conversations do not allow. And it becomes part of the piece's record: what materials went into it and when is exactly what the next repairer will need, and what your What was done sheet exists to hold.
(Go deeper) Two conservators give you different treatment proposals for the same chair. What should you conclude?
That you are looking at a normal state of affairs rather than at incompetence. The hiring guidance says plainly that conservators do not always agree about treatments and suggests speaking to several. What the difference gives you is visibility into the actual decision: compare what each would remove, what each would add, what each says it forecloses, and judge on technical and structural grounds as well as appearance, which is what that guidance recommends.
You inherit a mahogany chest with lifting veneer on the top and a drawer that sticks. A local shop advertises "antique restoration, free quotes, quick turnaround" and offers to collect it tomorrow and have it back in a week, stripped and polished, for a flat price. What do you do?
This offer matches the first warning sign in the hiring guidance almost word for word: a quick and inexpensive restoration proposed before anyone has examined the piece. The specific problem is that nobody has looked at the veneer, which is the finding that decides the job, and "stripped and polished" is a description of an irreversible operation agreed in advance of the examination. A flat price removes uncertainty about the bill, not about the work.
This is the chapter's method and it costs you nothing but a few days. A written examination with proposed treatment, expected results and estimated cost is what the hiring guidance says to expect, and the two added questions, what comes off and what goes on, will tell you quickly whether this shop has looked at your veneer or at its own calendar. If the answers are good, you have lost a week; if not, you have kept your options.
Lifting veneer is indeed within the wooden artifacts specialty, so this instinct is sound, and on a piece where the veneer or the history matters it may be the right call. What makes it premature is that you have not yet established what the veneer problem actually is, or decided what you want the chest to be, which is the previous chapter's question. A written examination from someone, possibly this shop, is how you find out.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.