Writing a condition report for a piece of furniture
A dated written record of one piece: what it is, what is wrong with it part by part, what the hazards pass found, and what you have decided to do and not do. This is the thing the manual is for.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. What a condition report is for
- 2. Photographs first
- 3. Observations, not conclusions
- 4. The pass that comes first
- 5. Walking the piece in a fixed order
- 6. The decision line
- 7. See it: the Ferris chest, half a report
- 8. Practice: one piece, one sitting
- 9. Your piece
- 10. Check your work
- 11. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
At minimum this chapter asks you to photograph one piece, walk it in a fixed order writing what you see, do the hazards pass, and date the result. The severity wording and the material for a professional are Go deeper on a first pass.
- Photograph the whole piece, then every fault, with something for scale. Before you touch anything (section 2).
- Walk the piece in a fixed order and write what you see, not what you think it means. "White ring, 4 inches, top near the left edge" (section 3, section 5).
- Do the hazards pass before you decide anything. It can change where the piece spends tonight (section 4, and What can hurt you in old furniture).
- Write the date, and write one thing you have decided not to do. The decision line is the part people leave out (section 6).
Minimum time: about 50 minutes for one piece. Done when: your report sheet has a date on it, a line for every part you could reach, and at least one thing you have decided not to do.
1. What a condition report is for Understand
Everything else in this manual produces a line on this sheet. That is the structure of the whole thing: the earlier chapters tell you what to look at, and this chapter is where what you saw gets written down in a form that is still useful in two years and still useful to somebody who has not seen the piece.
Three jobs it does, and they are worth separating because people usually have only the first in mind.
It stops you acting before looking. This is the one the manual is built around. Almost every bad outcome in this subject comes from someone deciding what to do before finding out what they had: stripping a finish that could have been cleaned, gluing a joint without removing the old glue, carrying a chest indoors with something living in it. Writing an observation down is slow in a way that is useful, because the act of writing "white ring, in the finish or in the wood, not established" surfaces the question you were about to skip.
It is the thing you send a professional. If you hire anyone, the first conversation goes better if you can send a dated description and photographs. The American Institute for Conservation's guidance on hiring runs in the same direction from the other end: a conservator should give you a written preliminary examination report with a description of the proposed treatment, expected results and estimated cost, for your review and approval before work begins, and a treatment report afterwards listing the materials and procedures used, which may include before-and-after photographic records and recommendations for continued care. Your report is the half of that exchange you can write yourself.
It outlives you and the piece's current situation. A crack measured and dated in January means something when it is measured again in July. A note saying which glue went into a joint tells the next repairer what they are dealing with. A record of a finish test saves the next person from running it again. The State Historical Society of Iowa's collections guidance for wooden objects puts monitoring, for temperature, humidity and pest activity, alongside handling and light as basic care, and monitoring only works if somebody wrote down the earlier reading.
A condition report is a record, not a diagnosis and not a valuation. It says "white ring, 4 inches, on the top near the left edge, in the finish rather than in the wood"; it does not say "water damage, needs refinishing," and it does not say "worth about."
The distinction matters for a practical reason rather than a philosophical one. An observation is still true in two years; a conclusion is only as good as your knowledge on the day you wrote it, and an observation written up as a conclusion leaves nobody, including you, anything to re-examine. Somebody reading "water damage" cannot tell what you actually saw. This manual does not value furniture at any point, and if value is in question that is an appraiser's work, before anything is done rather than after: Who to hire for furniture work says who.
2. Photographs first
Photograph before you touch. The reason is simple: as soon as you dust, move, open or test anything, the piece is no longer in the state it arrived in, and the state it arrived in is information. It is also the one state you have no way of recovering.
What to take, in order:
- The whole piece, from the front, square on. Then from each side and the back. Get the whole thing in frame.
- Each surface that has faults on it, straight on and with the light raking across rather than head on. A ring or a scratch is often invisible in flat light and obvious at a low angle: Surfaces, veneer and hardware uses the same trick for finding them.
- Each individual fault, close, with a ruler or a coin in frame for scale. Without a scale a photograph of a crack is a photograph of a line.
- The construction evidence: a drawer out and turned, a joint, the back, the underside, any label or stamp.
- Anything you are about to change. The test spot before the solvent goes on, the joint before you take it apart.
Practical notes that make the difference between a useful set and a folder nobody opens. Take more than you think you need, because going back is expensive and deleting is free. Put something in frame for scale in every close shot. Shoot in the best light you have and avoid flash, which flattens the surface and hides exactly the faults you are documenting. And name or caption the files the same day, while you still know which drawer was which.
Photographs are not themselves the report. They are evidence the report points at. On the sheet, the Photographed column is a tick saying that images exist; the description still has to be in words, because words are what a search, a reading six years later, and a professional's inbox can actually use.
3. Observations, not conclusions
This is the habit the chapter is really teaching, and it takes some discipline because conclusions are what the mind produces first.
| Conclusion (avoid) | Observation (write this) | What the second one preserves |
|---|---|---|
| Water damage on the top | White ring, about 4 in across, on the top, 6 in from the left edge. Raking light shows it sits in the finish rather than in the wood | The size, the position, and the finding that settles what can be done about it |
| Woodworm | About twenty round holes, roughly 1/16 in, in one end panel. Pale powder on the floor below. Swept on 14 March to check again | The count, the size, the location, and the test that is running |
| Needs regluing | Rear left joint moves about 1/8 in when the chair is pushed sideways. No crack visible in either member | Which joint, how much, and the fact that nothing is broken |
| Veneer damage | Veneer lifted along 3 in of the front right corner, springs back when pressed, no loss | The distinction between lifted and lost, which decides who does the work |
| Original finish | Denatured alcohol softened the finish on the inside of the right rail within seconds. Other surfaces untested | What was tested, where, and the fact that one test is not the piece |
| Hardware replaced | Four pulls, all matching. Two filled holes behind the top drawer's pull that the current pull does not use | The evidence, so somebody else can reach their own conclusion |
Notice what the right-hand column has in common: a measurement, a location, and no verb that implies cause. You will still form conclusions, and you should; they go in a separate place. On the sheets, the observation goes in the fault and extent columns, the reading goes in the cause column, which is labeled "as far as you can tell," and the decision goes on the plan sheet. Keeping the three apart is the whole method.
Convention One useful test: could somebody who has not seen the piece draw a rough sketch from your line? "Crack in the top" fails. "Crack running front to back in the top, 7 in long, starting 4 in from the right edge, open about 1/32 in at its widest" passes.
4. The pass that comes first
There is one part of the report that is not like the others, and it has to happen before the rest: the hazards pass. The reason is that its findings can change where the piece spends the night, and a pass done after the piece is in the living room is a pass that arrived too late.
What the pass covers: holes and fresh powder, a musty smell, visible mold, seams and folds in any upholstery, whether the piece is damp, whether it is painted and whether the paint might predate 1978, and the things that affect you rather than the piece, which are the solvents, the ventilation and the rags. The whole list is in What can hurt you in old furniture, and it sits on its own sheet in your condition report because it is a checklist rather than a description.
The hazards sheet is the same list for everyone. That is deliberate. The point of a pass is that you do all of it, including the lines you are confident about, because the line you skip is the one that mattered. Each line gets a date, what you found, and a decision from four options: clear, isolate it, it does not come in, or ask someone.
If the piece is outdoors or in a garage, do the pass there. If an active infestation is the finding, the American Institute for Conservation's instruction is to isolate the piece immediately in a large sealed plastic bag and call a conservator, or an exterminator familiar with conservation issues. That is much easier to do before the piece has been carried through the house.
5. Walking the piece in a fixed order
Use the same route every time. Not because the route matters, but because a fixed route is what stops you missing the back.
A route that works for most pieces: front, then left side, then back, then right side, then top, then the inside of every opening, then the underside. Within each surface: look at it flat on, then with light raking across it, then run a fingertip along every edge.
The parts worth a line each vary by what the piece is, which is why the Condition sheet in your condition report starts with rows chosen from your setup. A chair gets rear seat rail, front seat rail, side rails, legs, crest or back, stretchers and seat. A chest gets top, sides, drawer fronts, drawer sides, back, feet and pulls. A table gets top, apron, legs, stretchers and leaves. Add what the list missed and delete what your piece does not have.
For each part, three things: is the joint tight, loose, open or broken, which is Joints, racking and breaks; what surface faults are on it and how big, which is Surfaces, veneer and hardware; and whether what you are seeing is active or stable, which is the next distinction.
Active or stable is the single most useful column on the sheet and the one that needs a decision rather than a glance. A fault is active if it is still happening: powder still appearing after you swept it, a crack that was shorter last year, veneer lifting further, a joint that has loosened since you last looked. It is stable if it happened and stopped. The honest answer on a first visit is usually "not established," because active and stable are distinguished by looking twice with time in between. Writing "not established, swept and dated to check" is a better entry than guessing, and it is what sets up the second look.
6. The decision line
The last part of the report is the part people leave out, and it is the reason the report exists rather than being a list of faults.
On the plan sheet, every row is one thing, with four columns that matter: what it is, whether you are doing it, why, and who. The "why" column is not decoration. A decision without a reason leaves nothing to revisit, because in six months you will remember the decision and not the reason, and you will either repeat the reasoning from scratch or quietly reverse it.
And at least one row should be something you have decided not to do. This is the manual's own measure of whether the report worked. A report that produces only a list of jobs has usually skipped the looking; most pieces, read carefully, produce a list of careful things to do and a longer list of things to leave alone.
Examples of rows worth writing, from the fictional cases in this manual: "Not stripping the chest. Reason: the finish is shellac and tests sound, and the conservation guidance this manual cites holds that once an original finish is removed it is not recoverable." "Not regluing the cracked rail. Reason: the crack crosses the grain in a member that carries a person; sending it out." "Deciding later whether to lay the veneer down. Reason: pressing it suggests the substrate is sound, but that is not established."
Finally, the date. Every sheet carries one. A report without a date is a description of an unknown moment, and the whole value of the second reading depends on knowing when the first one was.
Severity wording that holds up
Three words do most of the work and are worth using consistently: stable, meaning it happened and is not continuing; active, meaning it is continuing now; and progressing, meaning you have two observations and it has got worse between them. The third one is the strongest claim in the set and needs two dated readings to justify it, which is precisely why it is worth having as a separate word.
Avoid the comparative words that feel precise and are not: minor, significant, severe, bad. They describe your reaction rather than the piece, and they do not survive a change of reader. A measurement and a position do survive.
Numbering and tagging detached parts
If something has come off, or comes off while you work, do not put it in a drawer and trust memory. The American Institute for Conservation's instruction is specific: place a detached element in a plastic bag labeled with its original location on the piece, until a conservator can reattach it. The label is the part people skip and it is the part that matters, because a molding that fits three places on a chest is worthless evidence once you have forgotten which one it came from.
For several parts, number them and record the numbers on the report, with a photograph showing where each came from. The same applies to hardware you remove: bag it, label it, and note which hole it came out of if the holes differ.
Keeping the report with the piece
The report is most valuable to the person who owns the piece after you. Export the file from your furniture file and keep a copy with the piece's papers, and if it is sold or passed on, send the file with it. The conservation habit this copies is ordinary in collections: the object and its record travel together, and a record that stays behind is a record that stops being true.
What to send a professional, and what to hold back
Send the identification, the condition sheet, the photographs including the scale shots, and your plan sheet showing what you want. That is enough for a useful first reply and it saves a visit.
Hold back your own diagnosis, or at least put it last. If you open with "it needs regluing," you have framed the question, and a professional reading a framed question is answering yours rather than looking at the piece. Send what you saw and let them tell you what it means. The hiring guidance's own warning signs point the same way: be wary of someone who proposes a quick and inexpensive job, who is reluctant to discuss materials and methods in detail, or who will not let you see work in progress. Someone who diagnoses from your diagnosis rather than from your observations is a near relation of the first of those.
7. See it: the Ferris chest, half a report See it
The Ferris family's painted pine chest. A blanket chest out of a relative's barn. Chipping paint, probably older than 1940, and a scatter of small round holes in one end with fresh pale powder on the barn floor underneath. Nobody has a goal yet: the question is whether it can come into the house.
The report, as far as it goes on day one:
What it is: "Blanket chest, pine, painted. Where it came from: inherited. Era: not established, paint and construction suggest pre-1940 but no clue read yet. Build: solid, no veneer seen. Finish: paint, not tested. Photographed: yes."
Condition, part by part: "End panel (left): about 25 round holes, roughly 1/16 in, over an area about 8 by 10 in. Active: not established. Paint chipping over roughly a third of that panel. Lid: paint chipping along the front edge, roughly 14 in. Joints: not examined, piece not moved."
The hazards pass: holes found, fresh pale powder found and swept on the day with the date written down. Musty smell: none. Visible mold: none. Painted: yes, and the paint may predate 1978. Decision on the pass: it does not come in.
The plan sheet, day one: one row. "What: nothing yet. Doing it or not: deciding later. Why: active infestation not ruled out, and the paint question is unanswered. Who: us. When: recheck the swept area in spring."
Known: the holes, the powder, the chipping paint, and that the piece has been in a barn.
Assumed, and it is the family's assumption: that the powder is fresh frass rather than old frass dislodged when the chest was moved. Sweeping and rechecking is the test, with the caveat that emergence happens mostly in spring and summer, so a check in November may be inconclusive.
Still open: the beetle family, which decides whether re-infestation is likely and which an extension entomologist or a licensed pest control operator identifies. And whether the paint contains lead, which nobody here can establish by looking.
Why this is a good report even though it decides almost nothing: it is dated, it records what was seen rather than what it means, it names both assumptions and who settles them, and its single plan row is a decision not to decide, with the reason. The family has done the most important thing available on day one, which was to leave the chest outside.
The published guidance behind this chapter:
- Hiring a conservation professional (American Institute for Conservation): what a written preliminary examination report and a treatment report should contain, and the warning signs quoted under Go deeper.
- Caring for Your Treasures (American Institute for Conservation): the furniture leaflet, for the detached-element instruction and the isolation instruction for an actively infested piece.
- Collections care: wooden objects and furniture (State Historical Society of Iowa): a short tips list that puts monitoring for temperature, humidity and pest activity alongside handling and light.
8. Practice: one piece, one sitting Practice
Minimum: one piece, photographs, the hazards pass, one line per part you can reach, and one decision not to do something. Time: about 50 minutes. Materials: a phone camera, a ruler or a coin for scale, a flashlight, and your condition report open.
- Photograph before touching. Whole piece from four sides, then every fault with a scale in frame.
- Do the hazards pass and give the piece a decision: clear, isolate it, it does not come in, or ask someone.
- Walk the piece in your fixed order, writing one line per part. Resist naming causes while you walk; that column comes after.
- Go back and fill the cause column, marked as your reading rather than a fact, and mark each fault active, stable or not established.
- Write the plan sheet: at least one thing you will do and at least one thing you will not, each with a reason.
- Check every sheet has today's date on it before you close the page.
The stranger test. Take your finished report, hide the photographs, and give the words to somebody who has not seen the piece. Ask them to sketch the piece and mark where the faults are. Whatever they get wrong is a line that needs a measurement, a position, or both. Fifteen minutes, and it is the fastest way to find the sentences that only work because you are standing in front of the thing.
9. Your piece Your piece
10. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does every sheet carry a date?
- Can a reader who has not seen the piece locate each fault from the words alone?
- Does each fault have a size, in inches, rather than an adjective?
- Are observations and causes in different columns, with the cause column marked as your reading?
- Is each fault marked active, stable or not established, with a recheck date where it is not established?
- Does the plan sheet carry at least one thing you decided not to do, with the reason?
- Did the hazards pass happen before the piece came indoors, or is it recorded why it could not?
Worked example
The Ferris chest's day-one report, checked against the criteria: dated, locatable, measured, causes held separately and marked unresolved, activity marked as not established with a recheck set for spring, and a plan row that is explicitly a decision to wait with the reason attached. The hazards pass was done outdoors and produced the decision that kept the chest there. It passes every criterion while settling almost nothing, which is the point.
Common mistakes
- Starting with the plan. The plan is the last sheet for a reason.
- Photographing after cleaning. The arrival state is the one you have no way of recovering.
- No scale in the close shots. A photograph of a crack with nothing beside it does not record its size.
- Adjectives instead of measurements. "Severe" is your reaction; "7 in long, open 1/32 in" is the crack.
- Marking everything stable on a first visit. Active and stable are distinguished by looking twice.
- Leaving the decision line empty. A report with no decision not to act has usually not done the looking.
- Doing the hazards pass indoors because it was raining. Then the decision it produces has nowhere to go.
What is still unresolved
A report does not tell you what to do, only what you have. Turning it into a plan is What not to do to old furniture, and why, and deciding who does the parts you are not doing is Who to hire for furniture work. A report also does not establish value, and this manual does not: an appraiser does, before any work rather than after.