Surfaces, veneer and hardware
The condition report

Surfaces, veneer and hardware: reading the faults

Rings, haze, crazing, scratches, lifting veneer and the wrong pulls. Name each fault and its cause before you decide anything about it, because the name decides whether anything can be done.

Start here Essentials

At minimum this chapter asks you to look across each surface at a low angle, give every fault a name and a size, and decide whether each one sits in the finish or in the wood. The fault-cause table and the hardware detail are Go deeper on a first pass.

  1. Look across the surface at a low angle under one light. Not down at it, across it (section 1).
  2. Name the fault before you decide anything about it. A named fault has a cause; an unnamed one invites a guess (section 2).
  3. Press gently along every veneer edge with a fingertip. Press; do not lift (section 4).
  4. Count the hardware and say whether it matches. Then write the faults onto the sheet with their sizes (your condition report).

Minimum time: about 35 minutes. Done when: every fault on your report has a name, a size and a line saying whether it goes through the finish.

1. Raking light, and why you have been missing things Understand

Most people look at a tabletop from above, under ceiling lights, and see a tabletop. Raking light means light arriving almost parallel to the surface, from one side, so that anything standing proud casts a shadow and anything recessed fills with one. It is how conservators and photographers look at surfaces, it costs nothing, and the first time you do it on a piece you thought you knew is usually a surprise.

How to do it: turn off the overhead light, take one lamp or a flashlight, put it at the far end of the surface at roughly the height of the surface itself, and look along the beam. Then move round and do it from the other three directions, because a scratch that runs with the light is invisible and the same scratch across the light is obvious.

What appears that was not there before: fine scratches and their direction, the outlines of old rings, sanding marks, ripples and dents in the surface, the slight step at the edge of a veneer patch, the texture of crazing, and the places where somebody has polished more than elsewhere.

Physical principle This works because almost every fault in this chapter is a change in surface geometry rather than a change in color. Flat light shows you color; raking light shows you shape. That is also why photographing faults flat on with a flash records so little, and why Writing a condition report asks for raking shots.

Before you start, one instruction from the dusting guidance, because this chapter has you touching surfaces. The Park Service's leaflet on dusting wood objects says to check the condition of a finish before handling or dusting it, and that finishes which are flaking, cracking or lifting at the edges, or wood surfaces that have splintered or have loose or lifting veneer, should not be dusted, with a conservator's advice requested instead. Look first, then decide whether to touch.

2. A fault has a name

Naming is not pedantry here. The name carries the cause, the cause carries the likely depth, and the depth decides whether anything in this manual applies. "Something white on the table" supports no decision; "a white ring in the finish" supports several.

Surface faults, their usual causes, and where they usually sit
FaultWhat it looks likeUsual causeUsually sits
White ringA pale ring or patch, often circularMoisture trapped in the finish film, from a glass or a damp object; on shellac, also alcoholIn the finish
Dark ring or stainA dark patch, often with a defined edgeLiquid that got through the finish into the wood; some are iron reacting with tannin in oakIn the wood
Haze or bloomA general cloudiness over an areaMoisture in the film, or wax applied in heat or humidityIn the finish, or in a wax layer above it
CrazingA fine network of cracks, like dried mud, visible in raking lightAn aging film shrinking and losing flexibilityIn the finish, through its thickness
Heat markA pale or blistered patch, sometimes with a visible edgeSomething hot set on the surfaceIn the finish, occasionally into the wood
ScratchA line, with direction, catching the lightAbrasionEither: see section 3
Gouge or dentMissing or compressed materialImpactIn the wood
Worn throughAn area where the finish has gone, often on edges and around handlesUse, over yearsThrough the finish into bare wood
Sticky or gummyA tacky or greasy surface, often overallAccumulated polish, or a finish breaking downAbove the finish, or the finish itself
Whitish specks in poresSmall white flecks in the open grain and in carvingA light-colored wax left in the poresIn a wax layer
Faded or bleachedColor lost, often shaded, often sharper where something satLight, visible and ultraviolet, over yearsIn the finish and in the wood
Lifting veneerA raised edge or a blister that moves under a fingertipGlue failure, often with moisture or heatAt the glue line under the facing
Missing veneerAn area where the facing is gone and the core showsLoss after lifting, or impactLoss of material
Ink or paint spotA discrete mark of another materialSomething spilled or appliedEither

Two of those have published treatments in this manual and the rest do not, which is worth knowing before you get attached to a fix. Convention A wax bloom is removable with mineral spirits, and whitish specks of wax can be picked out of the pores, both of which come from the Park Service's waxing guidance. Everything else in the table is named here and left alone in Cleaning furniture, waxing it, and reviving a tired finish, which limits itself to what a source states.

Limits

This chapter describes faults and their causes. It does not promise that any of them come out, and that is a deliberate limit rather than caution for its own sake.

A white ring, a bloom, a crazed film and a heat mark each have a popular method that sometimes works and a popular method that makes things worse, and which applies depends on the finish, its age and its soundness. This manual's reversible treatments are limited to what a published source states, which is cleaning, waxing, and taking a wax bloom off with mineral spirits. For the rest, the honest sequence is: name the fault, record its size and depth, find out what the finish is in Finding out what finish is on your furniture, and then decide with What not to do to old furniture, and why whether this is a job for you, for somebody else, or for nobody.

3. In the finish or in the wood

This is the single most useful line on the sheet, and it takes about ten seconds per fault.

Three tests, in order of how little they risk:

  1. Raking light. A fault that sits in the finish usually shows as a change in the surface: the film is dulled, clouded or cracked, and the surface geometry is different. A fault in the wood often shows no surface change, because the finish over it is intact and the color below has changed.
  2. A fingernail, drawn gently across. If it catches, there is a step, which means material has been removed or added. If it passes smoothly over a visible mark, the mark is below an intact surface.
  3. Look at it from several angles. A mark in the finish often changes appearance as you move, because you are seeing an optical effect inside a film. A mark in the wood looks much the same from everywhere.

Why it matters so much: a fault in the finish is a fault in a replaceable layer, and the finish is where the reversible work in this manual happens. A fault in the wood is permanent unless material is removed or added, and removing material from a surface means abrading or stripping, which this manual does not teach and which the conservation guidance treats as a last resort.

Where you genuinely cannot tell, write "not sure." It is a real answer and it is better than a confident wrong one, because the wrong one will be used.

4. Lifting or lost

Veneer gets its own section because the distinction between lifting and lost is the one that decides who does the work, and because the way most people test it is the way it becomes lost.

Lifting means the facing has released from its substrate but is still there: a raised edge, a bubble, a blister, a corner you can see light under. The wood is present and in place; the glue has failed.

Lost means the facing is gone over some area and the core is exposed. The material is not there and nothing will bring it back; replacing it is patching, and matching a patch to surrounding veneer is skilled work.

How to test, and the instruction matters: press, do not lift. Run a fingertip along the edge with light pressure and feel whether it moves and springs back. A lifted edge gives slightly and returns. Lifting the edge to look underneath is how a lifted edge becomes a broken one, because old veneer is thin, dry and brittle, and it breaks along the grain with very little provocation.

Snagging

The Park Service's cleaning leaflet gives the specific warning here: take care to avoid snagging the raised edges sometimes found on veneered and inlaid surfaces. A cloth passing over a lifted edge catches it and takes it off, which is how a recordable fault becomes a loss during the survey that was supposed to record it. The dusting leaflet goes further and says surfaces with loose or lifting veneer should not be dusted, and that a conservator's advice should be requested instead. Look, press, record, and keep cloths away from that edge.

What to record: lifted or lost, where, the area in inches, and whether pressing suggests the substrate under it is sound or crumbling. If a lifted area feels hollow and gritty rather than firm, the core may have deteriorated, which changes the job from re-adhering a facing to dealing with what is underneath.

Also record what is underneath where you can see it, from What your piece of furniture is actually made of: a facing lifting off solid wood and a facing lifting off swollen particleboard are different repairs with different prospects.

5. Hardware

Hardware is the most frequently replaced part of any piece of furniture, which makes it a poor dating clue and a good history clue.

What to record: how many pieces there are, whether they match each other, what they are made of, how they are fixed, and whether the fixing holes match the current hardware. That last one is where the information is. Filled holes, unused holes, or a plate that covers a shadow of a different shape are the common signs that what is on the piece now is not what was on it originally.

Count everything, including what is missing. "Four pulls, one missing from the second drawer, three matching, two filled holes behind the top drawer's pull" is a complete entry in one line.

On cleaning brass, the conservation guidance is more cautious than hardware polish advertising. The American Institute for Conservation's furniture leaflet notes that in most cases furniture hardware was intended to be brightly polished, so polishing is not in itself wrong, and then gives three qualifications. Polishes containing ammonia can cause long-term corrosion problems, so it suggests choosing one with a mild abrasive embedded in cotton wadding instead. Hardware should ideally be removed for cleaning so the polish does not reach the surrounding wood, and where that is impractical the polishing should be confined carefully to the metal. And as an alternative to a regular regimen of polishing, it offers having the hardware coated with clear lacquer.

Ask the authority Note what that last option implies: lacquering is a change to the object, it is reversible by somebody who knows how, and it is offered as a way to stop the repeated abrasion that polishing involves. Whether it suits your piece is a question for whoever would do it, and it belongs on the plan sheet as a decision rather than a job.

6. What light has already done

The last fault in this chapter is the one you cannot see as a fault, because it happened evenly and slowly.

The conservation position is blunt and worth quoting carefully because it closes off a hope people arrive with. The AIC furniture leaflet states that light, particularly visible and ultraviolet light, is very damaging to organic materials such as wood, and that damage from light is cumulative and irreversible. It says clear finishes often turn yellow or opaque in response to light, and that the color or cellular structure of the wood itself can also change.

Then the sentence that matters here: the resulting damaged finishes and bleached wood, it says, cannot be restored to their original color without stripping and refinishing, which it calls a practice not recommended.

Limits

So the honest answer to "can I even out this faded top" is usually no, not within what this manual covers. The color change is in the finish and in the wood, it accumulated over years, and the published route to reversing it is the one route the conservation guidance advises against taking.

What you can do is stop it getting worse, which is Keeping furniture from getting worse: move the piece out of direct sun, use blinds or curtains, and consider UV-filtering film on the windows, all of which that leaflet recommends. And you can record the fading with its pattern, because a sharp line where something sat on the top for twenty years is evidence about the piece's history and is worth keeping.

One practical observation that follows: a piece that is evenly faded has been in light evenly, and a piece with a sharp shadow has had something on it. Both are findings. Record the pattern, not just the fact.

Go deeper

What crazing tells you

Crazing is a fine network of cracks through the thickness of a finish film, and in raking light it looks like dried mud or like a crackle glaze. It happens as a film ages, shrinks and loses flexibility while the wood underneath keeps moving seasonally.

Two things worth taking from it. It is a sign of an old film rather than a recent accident, which makes it one of the few faults that carries information about age, and it sits alongside the finish evidence in How old your furniture is. And it changes how the surface should be handled: a crazed film has lost flexibility and has many edges, so wiping it is more likely to lift flakes than wiping a sound one. The cleaning guidance's own rule, that cleaning should be attempted only on surfaces with a sound, stable, clear finish, rules out most crazed surfaces.

Inlay, marquetry and banding

Inlay and marquetry are decorative surfaces built from many small pieces of veneer and sometimes other materials, and they are specialist work for a reason that is structural rather than aesthetic. A conservation paper on marquetry surfaces, by a practitioner working in this field, describes marquetry as composed of extremely diverse hardwood elements, often mixed with materials such as ivory, bone, tortoiseshell, mother-of-pearl, metals, straw or horn, and notes that in much early work the solid wood groundwork supporting the marquetry is itself the major cause of the damage. It describes current workshop approaches including rehydrating the original animal glue in place under the veneer with controlled heat, which is about as far from a home repair as this subject gets.

What to take from that: a lifted edge on a marquetry panel is not the same job as a lifted edge on a plain veneered drawer front, the material under it may be the thing that failed, and the American Institute for Conservation lists veneer, marquetry and boulle within its Wooden Artifacts specialty, which tells you who does this work. Record it carefully, including what the decorative materials appear to be, and keep cloths and solvents away from it.

What a replaced pull costs you, and what it does not

Replaced hardware is extremely common and is not a fault in the sense that a crack is. What it costs is evidence: original hardware is part of the record of how a piece was made and used, and a filled hole is the trace of a decision somebody made. In the refinishing argument that What not to do to old furniture, and why sets out, hardware sits on the same side of the ledger as the finish, which is to say that both sides agree that original material carries information and that replacing it removes some.

What it does not cost is the ability to use the piece, and this manual does not tell you that a replaced pull has reduced anything measurable, because it does not value furniture. Record what is there, record the evidence of what was there, keep any original hardware you remove in a labeled bag, and let that be enough.

Dust, and why it is a fault rather than a nuisance

The Park Service treats dust as an agent of deterioration rather than as untidiness, and the reasoning is worth knowing. Its dusting leaflet notes that hard sharp particles such as those of siliceous origin tend to cause abrasion, while organic particles are more likely to cause chemical damage, and that dust attracts water vapor and so creates a microclimate of higher relative humidity next to the object. Its leaflet on upholstered furniture adds that dust acts as an attractant and a food source for insects.

So dust on a surface is a slow abrasive, a local humidity problem and an insect attractant at once, which is why the cleaning chapter puts dusting first and treats it as the one routine action worth doing. The same leaflet is also the reason this chapter says look before you touch: on an unstable finish, dusting is itself a damaging act.

7. See it: three surfaces read See it

Fictional example

Dana's chest: the white ring. One ring about 4 inches across on the top, 6 inches in from the left edge.

What raking light showed: the ring reads as a dulled, slightly cloudy area within the surface rather than as a stain under it. A fingernail drawn across it does not catch. Moving round the table, the ring's appearance changes with the angle.

Known: the fault is a white ring, 4 inches, in the finish rather than in the wood, on a surface whose finish tested as shellac.

Assumed: that it was caused by moisture or by something alcoholic standing on the top. Both are consistent with a shellac film, and nothing Dana can see distinguishes them.

Still open: whether anything should be done about it. This manual's published treatments do not include ring removal, so the chapter stops at the name and the depth. Under the assumption that the finish is original shellac, this is a question for Who to hire for furniture work, and Dana's plan sheet records it as "deciding later."

On the report: "Top: white ring, 4 in across, 6 in from left edge. In the finish; fingernail does not catch; appearance changes with viewing angle. Finish is shellac. Cause: moisture or alcohol, not distinguished."

Fictional example

Priya's sideboard: the lifting corner. Veneer lifting at one front corner.

What pressing found: an area about 3 inches along the front edge and about 1 inch deep where the facing gives slightly under a fingertip and springs back. It feels firm rather than hollow. No facing is missing. At the very corner, the edge of the facing is visible and the core beneath is a pale, uniform, fine material.

Known: lifting rather than loss, over roughly 3 square inches, with a core that is visible at the corner.

Assumed: that the substrate under the lifted area is sound, on the evidence that it feels firm rather than crumbly. That is a fingertip's reading through a facing and it is not conclusive.

Still open: whether the facing can be laid back down and by whom. Pressing along it begins to answer the question and somebody with the piece in front of them finishes it.

Why Priya does not lift the edge to look: because old veneer is thin and brittle, and the inspection that would answer the question is also the action most likely to turn a lifted edge into a missing one. The report records what pressing showed and leaves it there.

Fictional example

Marcus's chairs: the gummy surface. All four chairs have a sticky, greasy surface.

What the survey found: in raking light the surface is uneven in sheen, with the gloss higher where hands have been. A fingernail leaves a visible track that slowly disappears. Mineral spirits on a swab, from the finish test, lifted a brown greasy film across three swabs, and the surface under it was dull but firm.

Known: there is an accumulated layer on top of the finish that mineral spirits removes, and the finish under it did not react to the stronger solvents.

Assumed: that the layer is years of polish rather than a failing finish, supported by the firm surface underneath.

Still open, and it outlives these chairs: whether the polish contained silicone. The Park Service's leaflet on the subject says the majority of commercial furniture polishes contain silicone in some form, that it is found in almost all liquid and aerosol wax preparations, and that where it is known or suspected the fact should be recorded. So Marcus records it as suspected rather than establishing it, which is what the leaflet's own wording invites.

The published guidance behind this chapter:

  • Caring for Your Treasures (American Institute for Conservation): the furniture leaflet, for light damage being cumulative and irreversible, bleached wood and color, dusting cautions near loose veneers and mounts, and the brass hardware guidance in section 5.
  • Dusting wood objects (National Park Service, Conserve O Gram 7/5, September 2002): why dust damages a surface, and the instruction not to dust an unstable finish or lifting veneer.
  • Silicone in furniture waxes and polishes (National Park Service, Conserve O Gram 7/6, July 1993): how common silicone is in polishes, and the instruction to record it where known or suspected.
  • Upholstered furniture: agents of deterioration (National Park Service, Conserve O Gram 7/4, July 1993): dust as an abrasive and as insect food, and the wood-boring beetle exit-hole sizes it gives.

8. Practice: the raking light survey Practice

Minimum: one surface, surveyed in raking light from two directions, with every fault named, measured and given a depth. Time: about 35 minutes. Materials: one lamp or a flashlight, a ruler, a phone camera, and your condition report open. Nothing is applied to the surface in this exercise.

  1. Turn the overhead light off and set one light at the far end of the surface, low down.
  2. Look along the beam, then move round and look from each of the other three sides. Mark nothing yet; just look.
  3. Photograph what the raking light shows, with the light in the same place and a ruler in frame.
  4. Name and measure each fault, using the table in section 2, and write its position in inches from a named edge.
  5. Give each one a depth: in the finish, into the wood, or not sure, using the three tests in section 3.
  6. Press along every veneer edge, recording lifted or lost and the area. Press only.
  7. Count the hardware and record matches, absences and any holes that the current hardware does not use.
Go deeper

The cause column exercise. Go back over your fault list and write, for each one, what you think caused it and what would have to be true for that to be wrong. For a white ring: "a wet glass; wrong if nobody has put a drink on this piece, in which case look for a damp cloth or a plant." The point is not to be right. It is that the second half of each sentence usually names an observation you have not made yet, and those are the ones worth going back for.

9. Your piece Your piece

10. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does every fault have a name from the table rather than a description of your reaction to it?
  • Does every fault have a size in inches and a position measured from a named edge?
  • Does every fault carry a depth: in the finish, into the wood, or not sure?
  • Is veneer recorded as lifted or lost, with an area, and did you press rather than lift?
  • Is the hardware counted, including what is absent and any holes that do not match?
  • Did you look in raking light from more than one direction?

Worked example

Dana's white-ring entry names the fault, measures it, positions it from a named edge, gives its depth with the two tests that established it, names the finish it sits in, and records the cause as undistinguished between two candidates. Checked against the criteria it passes on every line that applies. What it deliberately does not do is say what will remove it, which is the chapter's own limit.

Common mistakes

  • Surveying under a ceiling light. Flat light hides most of what is in this chapter.
  • Lifting a veneer edge to see how far it goes. The commonest way a recordable fault becomes a loss.
  • Dusting first. On an unstable finish or lifting veneer, dusting is the damaging act; look before you touch.
  • Writing "scratched" for a whole surface. Count them, or describe the area and direction; one line for a top tells the next reader nothing.
  • Guessing the depth rather than writing "not sure." The depth drives the decision, so a wrong confident answer is worse than an honest blank.
  • Skipping the hardware because it looks fine. The filled hole behind a matching pull is the kind of evidence that only turns up when counted.
  • Assuming a fault must be fixable. Several in the table have no published reversible treatment, and faded wood has none this manual will offer.

What is still unresolved

This chapter names faults; it does not remove them. What may be done about a surface depends on which finish is on it, which is Finding out what finish is on your furniture, and what is permitted on that finish is Cleaning furniture, waxing it, and reviving a tired finish. Whether the piece should be changed is What not to do to old furniture, and why, and who does the work you are not doing is Who to hire for furniture work.

11. Knowledge check and scenario

Why does the manual insist on raking light rather than just good overhead light?
Because almost every fault in this chapter is a change in surface geometry rather than in color, and flat light shows color while raking light shows shape. Scratches, crazing, dents, old ring outlines and the step at the edge of a patch all appear when the light arrives nearly parallel to the surface and disappear when it comes from above.
A fingernail drawn across a white mark does not catch, and the mark changes appearance as you move round the table. What have you established?
That the mark is very likely in the finish rather than in the wood: nothing has been removed or added at the surface, and the changing appearance is an optical effect within a film. That is the line on the report that matters, because a fault in the finish sits in a replaceable layer while a fault in the wood does not.
You find a veneer edge lifting along three inches. Why does the manual tell you to press rather than lift?
Because old veneer is thin, dry and brittle, and lifting an edge to look underneath is the action most likely to break it, turning a fault you could record into material you have lost. Pressing tells you what you need for the report, which is whether it moves and springs back and whether the substrate feels firm. The cleaning guidance gives the same warning about cloths snagging raised edges.
(Go deeper) Someone asks you to even out the faded top of a mahogany table. What is the honest answer?
That within what this manual covers, there is probably no way to do it. Light damage is described in the conservation guidance as cumulative and irreversible, and it says that bleached wood and damaged finishes cannot be restored to their original color without stripping and refinishing, which it calls a practice not recommended. What is available is stopping it getting worse: out of direct sun, blinds or curtains, and UV-filtering film on the windows.
An inherited side table has a cloudy haze over most of the top and a lifted veneer edge along the front. You have a soft cloth, some furniture polish from the cupboard, and an afternoon. What do you do?
Two problems. The conservation guidance is explicit that furniture does not need to be fed, that drying oils build a gummy insoluble coating which darkens and obscures the grain, and that non-drying oils such as lemon oil attract and entrap dirt; the Park Service adds that most commercial polishes contain silicone, which leaves a film that is difficult to remove and interferes with future treatment. And a cloth passing over a lifted veneer edge is how that edge comes off.
This is the chapter's order and it keeps every option open. The haze gets a name, a size and a depth; the veneer gets pressed rather than lifted and recorded as lifted or lost with its area; and nothing is applied to a surface whose finish has not been identified. What to do next comes from the finish test and then the cleaning chapter.
Dusting is usually the right first action and the cleaning chapter puts it first for good reasons. Here it is premature for one specific reason: the dusting guidance says not to dust a surface with loose or lifting veneer and to ask a conservator instead. Survey first, find where the lifted edge runs, and then dust everything except that area.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.