Identifying the finish: the solvent sequence
Reference

Identifying the finish: the solvent sequence

The test as a decision table, in the order the solvents go on, with what each answer rules in and rules out, and the one result that means stop rather than carry on.

The sequence is published by Bob Flexner, a finishing writer, in Popular Woodworking in April 2016. The stop condition and the solvent cautions come from the National Park Service's Conserve O Gram leaflets. Finding out what finish is on your furniture is the chapter that runs it.

Before you start

  • Pick a place nobody will ever see and where the finish is sound: an inside face, an underside, the back of a leg. Not on damage, and not on a top.
  • Use a fresh swab for each solvent. A swab carrying mineral spirits into the alcohol step confuses the result.
  • Read the labels and the safety data sheets, and ventilate throughout the work and the drying. That is the Park Service's own instruction to staff. Mineral spirits, sold as paint thinner, is a Class II combustible liquid with a flash point of 102 to 110 °F.
  • Decide where the rags go before you open anything. Flat, single layer, on concrete, outdoors.

The sequence

What to apply, in order, and what each result means
StepSolventReactionWhat it rules inWhat it rules out
1Mineral spirits (also naphtha, turpentine)A waxy smear on the swab; the spot dulls or cloudsWax on the surface. Keep wiping with fresh swabs until nothing more lifts, then dry and go onNothing about the finish underneath yet. Until the wax is off you are testing the wax
1Mineral spiritsThe finish itself softens or goes tackyStop: see the box belowEverything. This result ends the session
1Mineral spiritsDirt lifts, finish unchangedMineral spirits is a safe cleaning agent for this surface, which is what the cleaning chapter needs to knowA wax layer, and a fragile finish
2Denatured alcoholThe surface goes sticky, or the finish dissolves; color may come off on the swabShellacLacquer, varnish and the cured coatings
2Denatured alcoholNothingNot shellac. ContinueShellac, in the place you tested
3Lacquer thinnerThe finish dissolves or goes stickyLacquerVarnish and the newer cured finishes
3Lacquer thinnerGoes soft and tacky rather than dissolvingPossibly a water-based finish, which the source says goes soft and tacky in lacquer thinner, toluene and xyleneLittle on its own: confirm against the date range below
3Lacquer thinnerNothing, after nothing at steps 1 and 2"Varnish or one of the newer more-solvent-resistant finishes," in the source's words. A group, not a nameWax, shellac and lacquer
Limits

The stop. The Park Service's cleaning leaflet says that if the mineral spirits softens the finish, do not attempt to clean the piece, and consult a furniture conservator for professional assistance. That is a stop rather than an instruction to work more gently or to try a weaker solvent. Record the result and leave the surface alone; Who to hire for furniture work is what follows.

The group. When nothing reacts, the honest entry on your report is the group rather than "varnish". The group spans oil-based varnish, polyurethane, catalyzed conversion finishes, polyester and UV-cured coatings, whose earliest and latest members are separated by most of a century. For every cleaning and waxing decision in this manual, knowing the surface is solvent-resistant is sufficient.

The assumption under everything. The method's own author states it: the reading assumes you are dealing with an original, not refinished, finish. A refinished piece tests as its newest coat, which tells you about the last person who worked on it rather than about the piece.

What each answer suggests about a date

The period dates below are from the same article, and they are this manual's one dating clue with a published source behind it. They date the finish, which on a refinished piece is a different thing from the piece.

Period dates, after Flexner (2016)
FinishWhat the article saysReading it as a date
Wax or linseed oilWhat makers used in the eighteenth century and earlier, with what was availableConsistent with early work, and with any later piece finished this way
ShellacAlcohol-soluble resins widely available by the 1820s; shellac the overwhelmingly dominant finish for the next hundred yearsA floor around the 1820s, and most likely before about the 1920s if original
Nitrocellulose lacquerAvailable in the 1920s, slowly replacing shellacA floor in the 1920s
Catalyzed finishesFurther resins from the 1960s began replacing lacquer, mainly catalyzed; polyester and UV-cured later, no date givenA floor around the 1960s, within the solvent-resistant group
Water-basedIntroduced in the 1980s and 1990s to reduce solvent emissionsA floor in the 1980s

How old your furniture is uses these alongside the construction clues, and explains why this manual prints no date ranges for saw marks, dovetails, screws or nails.

What each finish tolerates

How the families behave, and what each is vulnerable to
FinishHow it curesRedissolves inDamaged byCleaning and waxing
WaxSolvent evaporates; wax remainsMineral spirits, naphtha, turpentineHeat, abrasion, its own solventsRemovable, which is why wax is called a sacrificial layer
ShellacSolvent evaporates; the film stays solubleDenatured alcohol; attacked by lacquer thinnerAlcohol, water, heatKeep water off it; clean with mineral spirits on a cloth. Waxing suitable on a sound film
Nitrocellulose lacquerSolvent evaporates; the film stays solubleLacquer thinnerSolvents; crazes as it agesThe published cleaning routine applies. Treat a crazed surface gently
Oil-based varnish and polyurethaneCures chemically; does not redissolveNothing in this testAbrasion, light, eventual embrittlementNamed by conservation guidance as best maintained with a thin coat of paste wax, no more than once a year
Catalyzed, polyester and UV-curedCure chemically, often very hardNothing in this testImpact and abrasion rather than solventsAs above; these are the most tolerant surfaces here
Water-basedCoalesces as water leavesSoft and tacky in lacquer thinner, toluene, xyleneSolvents, some cleaning productsTest any wax on a hidden spot first, as the waxing guidance asks for a first waxing
Oil finishCures in and just below the surfaceNot a film to dissolveWear through to bare woodClean sparingly; mineral spirits keeps lifting for as long as you wipe
PaintVariesNot tested hereVariesThe cleaning guidance stops at dusting unless you are trained. Read the hazards chapter first
UnfinishedNo finishNot applicableWater raises the grain; dirt enters the poresNo water. Paste wax is not recommended on bare wood: it penetrates the pores and is nearly impossible to remove
Fictional example

Dana's walnut chest. Tested on the underside of the top rail. Mineral spirits lifted gray dirt and no wax smear, and the finish did not soften. Denatured alcohol made the spot sticky within seconds, with a faint brown on the swab.

Reading the table: row 3 at step 1 (safe to clean with mineral spirits, no wax), then row 1 at step 2 (shellac). Step 3 was not needed.

What it changed: water stays off this piece, which rules out the soap-and-water step of the cleaning routine; and the white ring on the top is probably a mark in a shellac film rather than a stain in the wood, which raking light can test further.

Still assumed: that the rest of the chest carries the same finish as that one rail, and that the shellac is original. One test spot is one test spot.

What to write down

  • Where you tested, specifically enough to find the spot again.
  • What each solvent did, including the ones that did nothing. A negative is a result.
  • Whether the finish softened under mineral spirits, recorded separately, because that is the stop condition rather than an identification.
  • Whether there was wax, recorded as a layer rather than as the finish.
  • The group rather than a name, where nothing reacted.

All of it goes on the What it is sheet in your condition report, which has a column for the finish and a column for what the solvent test did.